- Send a commerical or charity enquiry; please purchase our restaurant database instead
- Cancel or change an existing reservation; please call the restaurant on 01496 302310
- Request a booking if you have requested a booking at the same date/time elsewhere
18 Restaurant at The Machrie Hotel


18 Restaurant at The Machrie Hotel restaurant reviews




Average rating: 3.3
We used the restaurant for breakfast while staying at the hotel. Supposedly serves 7-10am, arrived at 9ish and was chaotic. THE worst coffee, absolutely atrocious (see photo), then wondered why there was a lot of demand for "proper" coffees? Worst of all (as someone with coeliac (gluten free)) was their attitude to allergens. Asked for the allergen menu (a legal requirement), told to scan the QR code on the menu. Doesn't work (takes you to a website of the same menu with the same QR code). Asked for a paper copy. Waited ten minutes and then the older lady who was out waitress tried to pressure me into ordering before I'd seen the allergen menu and confirmed what was safe for me to eat. Told they "couldn't find" the paper allergen menu, meaning they didn't have one available, despite this being a legal requirement. Had to go through each breakfast item individually to confirm it was GF. Got poached eggs on toast with beans. Obviously dreadful Schar gluten free bread, which they buy because it's longer dated, even though it's disgusting. Partner had the full Scottish, which did not match the standard of the hotel. No other gluten free options except fruit & yogurt.




Award winning afternoon tea lists featuring 18 Restaurant at The Machrie Hotel
18 Restaurant at The Machrie Hotel guide awards history
| Date | Guide | Old Award | New Award |
|---|---|---|---|
| May 2025 | AA Guide | Added to Guide | ![]() |
| March 2023 | Michelin Guide | ![]() |
Not Listed |
| October 2019 | Michelin Guide | Not Listed | ![]() |
18 Restaurant at The Machrie Hotel FAQs
18 Restaurant at The Machrie Hotel is not currently listed in the Michelin Guide, however the restaurant previously held a standard Michelin Guide listing until March 2023.
18 Restaurant at The Machrie Hotel currently holds 1 AA Rosette, which was awarded in May 2025.
The Machrie Hotel, Port Ellen, Isle of Islay, PA42 7AN.
To email 18 Restaurant at The Machrie Hotel now, please click here
Yes, we believe 18 Restaurant at The Machrie Hotel (or the associated hotel/parent venue) serves afternoon tea. Please note that afternoon tea may not be provided by the same restaurant team and may be served in a different dining area within The Machrie Hotel. Please visit the restaurant website to learn more.
